The gift guide worth reading this year is the one small businesses built themselves. Carol Roth's 2026 Small Business Holiday Gift Guide gathers hundreds of independent makers in a single list, and Smythe and Digby appears in it at entry 356, listed for our design-your-own velvet loafers. What follows is a short, honest way to shop a guide like that, and a case for the gift a man designs himself.

What makes a small business gift guide worth reading?

Most gift guides are assembled by editors working from press releases. This one works the other way around. The entries come in from the businesses and the people around them, written in their own words, and the range shows it. Food, games, jewellery, clothing, and one made-to-order shoemaker, all sitting side by side with no ranking and no pay-to-play ordering. Reading it feels like walking a market street where every stallholder can tell you how their thing gets made.

That matters for the person giving the gift. When you buy from a maker, the money goes to a workshop, the order gets handled by someone who knows your name is attached to it, and the object arrives with a story the recipient can actually be told. You can read the whole guide at Carol Roth's 2026 Small Business Holiday Gift Guide, and our entry sits at number 356.

Why does a gift the recipient designs himself land differently?

A bought gift says you thought about him. A designed gift says he gets a say in it. With a pair of Smythe and Digby velvet loafers, the recipient opens the Design Studio, chooses his velvet, and puts his own monogram on the vamp in the thread colour he wants. The pair that arrives is the pair he pictured. Nobody else owns the same one, because nobody else made the same choices.

The numbers worth knowing. A pair of Smythe and Digby velvet loafers is $325, and the monogram in any thread colour is included in that price. Every pair is made to order in four to six weeks, so a gift order belongs at the start of the season rather than the end of it.

What do groomsmen actually keep?

Ask a man what remains from the weddings he has stood in and the answer is rarely the flask. Couples have taken to outfitting the whole wedding party in matching velvet loafers, each man designing his own pair around his own monogram, and those shoes stay in the rotation long after the day itself. The flask gets a laugh at the rehearsal dinner, the shoes get worn for a decade. If your gift list includes a groom, or a man about to stand beside one, our wedding loafers page is where that order starts.

How do you give a pair as a gift?

Start at the Design Studio and choose Design Your Pair. You can design the pair for him, monogram and all, or hand him the experience and let him build his own. Either way, order with the calendar in mind. Made to order means made for one person, and four to six weeks of making cannot be hurried at the checkout. Give the gift early in the season and the pair arrives with time to spare.

A gift guide is only as good as the gifts that come out of it. This one is full of small businesses worth your money, and we are pleased to keep that company.

Frequently asked questions

Where can I read the Carol Roth gift guide?
The full list is published as the 2026 Small Business Holiday Gift Guide on Carol Roth's website. Smythe and Digby appears at entry 356, for design-your-own velvet loafers.

How much are the velvet loafers in the guide?
A pair is $325. The monogram, embroidered on the vamp in any thread colour, is included in that price.

How long does a made-to-order pair take?
Every pair is made to order and takes four to six weeks. Ordering early in the season is the sensible way to give one as a gift.

Can a whole wedding party order matching pairs?
Yes. Couples regularly outfit an entire wedding party in matching velvet loafers, with each man designing his own pair and his own monogram.